Which is best for under eye crepiness? Plexaderm vs Sudden Change

by Betty
(Arizona)

Which is the best temporary treatment for under-eye crepiness? I've tried Plexaderm, and it just cakes up and peels off as soon as I move my face.

I heard Sudden Change is also a temporary solution for crepey skin under and around the eyes, but I don't see it anywhere online or in drugstores.

You talk about crepey skin a lot on your website. What have you found that works? Please don't suggest lasers, fillers, or Fraxel treatments. I'm over 70 and have medical issues, so I don't want to try anything that drastic.

I'd just like to find something easy to use that can make the skin under my eyes look a little smoother and better.

Thanks so much,
Betty

Editor's Note:

Hi Betty!

Oh boy, do I know what you're talking about! I've been dealing with under-eye puffiness and crepey skin for years. In fact, my right eye has been puffy since I was a teenager, long before wrinkles were even a concern.

And I've tried just about every instant eye-tightening serum I could get my hands on!

Of the ones I've tried, Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx Eye works best for me. But let me tell you a little about the others, too.

What about Sudden Change?

Yes, I've used Sudden Change! In fact, I tried it years ago, when there weren't nearly as many instant eye-tightening products to choose from.

It's still around, although it may not be as easy to find in stores.

Like Plexaderm, it temporarily tightens the skin as it dries. But here's the catch: these types of products can also leave a visible film, especially if you use too much or your skin is dry.

Since it's been years since I used Sudden Change, I can't tell you how the current version compares with Plexaderm. But I wouldn't automatically assume it will solve your peeling problem.

Why I prefer Peter Thomas Roth

I've tried Plexaderm, Sudden Change, Peter Thomas Roth, and plenty of other instant eye-tightening products over the years.

For my skin, Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx Eye gives me the results I like best.

That doesn't mean it's perfect. I've had my share of problems with these products, including white residue and that overly tight feeling you can get if you apply too much.

But once I figured out how to use PTR properly, I liked the way it worked on my under-eye area.

If you're curious about the other products I've tried, I compare several of them in my Plexaderm vs. competitors review.

I even tested how long PTR lasts compared with Plexaderm

I was curious whether one actually held up longer than the other, so I did my own little test.

I compared Peter Thomas Roth and Plexaderm on my skin to see how long the tightening effect lasted and how they looked as the hours went by.

You can see my results in my Plexaderm vs. Peter Thomas Roth wear-time test.

What can you do about the cracking and peeling?

Betty, before spending money on another serum, I'd try changing how you apply the one you already have.

Sometimes the problem isn't just the product. It's how much you apply, what's underneath it, or how well it dries.

And crepey under-eye skin can make things even trickier!

I've put together some tips for preparing dry, crepey under-eyes before applying an instant tightener.

And if your biggest complaint is that the serum breaks apart when you smile or move your face, take a look at why instant eye tighteners crack and peel.

One thing I've learned from using these products for so long is that a very thin layer usually looks better than trying to get extra tightening by applying more.

And remember, these serums are temporary fixes. They can make crepey skin and fine lines look smoother for a while, but they don't actually get rid of wrinkles.

So Betty, if you're thinking of trying something besides Plexaderm, I'd consider Peter Thomas Roth. It's the one I prefer, although your results may be different from mine.

Hope this helps! And if you decide to give Sudden Change another look, I'd love to hear how it works for you.

Best,
Linda