How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Older Women (That Won’t Tug or Smudge on Wrinkled Lids)

by: Linda Robison / Facial Fitness Specialist @ ABZ

Search Anti-Aging Beauty Zone

Choosing eyeliner gets trickier as we get older—especially when lids become thinner, drier, or a little wrinkled. Many formulas start to smudge, skip, or settle into lines when all you want is a smooth, flattering finish.

This guide breaks down what to look for (and what to avoid) when choosing eyeliner for mature skin—so you can find one that glides on easily and enhances your eyes without the fuss.

Not sure what suits your eye shape? Here's how to apply eyeliner for different mature eye shapes—including hooded, almond, and deep-set eyes.

Different eyeliners for wrinkled eyelids.

Want product suggestions? Check out my list of best eyeliners for aging eyes (including my fav). They’re smudge-proof, easy to apply, and super gentle on mature skin.

Why do some eyeliners fail on wrinkled eyelids?

Quick Answer: Many eyeliners fail on mature eyelids because they’re either too creamy (settling into lines), too dry (tugging the skin), overly pigmented (creating harsh lines), or not long-lasting (smudging easily).

Not all eyeliners are created equal—some just don’t work well on mature skin. Many women over 50 tell me they’ve stopped wearing eyeliner altogether because it’s too tricky to apply or doesn't look right.

That's a shame because I truly believe the right eyeliner can brighten older eyes, define your face, and even add a hint of sexy!

Common problems include:

  • Too Creamy: Smudges and settles into fine lines.
  • Too Dry: Tugs on delicate skin and skips when applied.
  • Too Pigmented: Harsh lines can make eyes look smaller or tired.
  • Not Long-Wearing: Fades or transfers onto eyelids throughout the day.

I've found the key is choosing an eyeliner that glides smoothly without smudging or fading. I'll show you exactly what to look for below.

ABZ Tip: Want step-by-step video with my pics on applying eyeliner? Check out my How to Apply Eyeliner guide for a full tutorial!

What to look for in eyeliner for aging eyes

When shopping for eyeliner, focus on the formula, finish, and staying power to avoid smudging and creasing.

1. Best formula for wrinkled eyelids

  • Gel Pencils – Soft, blendable, and long-wearing.
  • Waxy Pencils – Smooth application and less likely to smudge.
  • Cream-Based Gel Liners – Glides easily and stays put.

Avoid: Liquid eyeliners that dry too fast, leading to cracking.

2. Waterproof vs. Smudge-proof

  • Waterproof eyeliners - Great for all-day wear but can be drying.
  • Smudge-proof eyeliners - Easier to remove but still long-wearing.

Best Choice? If you have dry or sensitive skin, go for smudge-proof over waterproof to prevent flaking and irritation. I also find smudge-proof liners easier to work with and remove.

3. Matte vs. Satin vs. Shimmer

  • Matte Finish: Best choice for mature skin; doesn't emphasize wrinkles.
  • Satin or Soft-Shimmer Finish: Gives a subtle glow without highlighting lines.

Avoid Metallic or Glittery Finishes: Can emphasize texture and fine lines.

Which eyeliner colors flatter mature eyes best?

Ok, the general rule of thumb for color selection is:

  • Fair skin: Look for softer shades like taupe and light browns.
  • Darker skin: Embrace vibrant tones like plum and teal.
  • Brown or hazel eyes: Try purples, greens, or golds to enhance your natural eye color.

That's just a general guideline—not a strict rule. I’m in my 60s with fair skin and still wear black eyeliner—but I go for softer formulas that don’t look harsh or overdone.

Want to skip the trial and error? See my top eyeliner picks for mature lids.

Can dark eyeliner make you look older?

Some people say to avoid black eyeliner as you age, but it’s not always that simple. I’ve tried lighter shades like taupe and brown, and honestly—they can sometimes make my eyes look more tired or washed out.

Instead, I go for a softer black pencil or a dark chocolate cream gel liner—formulas I can build gradually without creating harsh lines. The key is in the texture and pigment, not just the color.

If you're worried about black looking too heavy, try adding a subtle flick. These eyeliner flick tips for hooded and older eyes show how to lift and define your eyes without tugging or overlining.

How to stop eyeliner from smudging or fading

The best ways to prevent eyeliner from smudging or fading include prepping your lids properly, using setting powder, and setting eyeliner with eyeshadow.

  • Start with a smooth base - Apply a light layer of primer or concealer.
  • Use a setting powder - Lightly dust translucent powder over your liner.
  • Tightline for a natural look - Apply eyeliner to the upper waterline.
  • Set with eyeshadow - A similar-toned powder will keep it locked in.

Want step-by-step details with helpful pictures? See 10 Smart Tricks Eyeliner Makeup Tricks You Need to Try!

Struggling with eyeliner in the heat? Check out my summer eyeliner tricks to help your look stay fresh—even on hot, humid days.

Final Takeaway: 

There’s no one-size-fits-all eyeliner for older women—but a few simple rules make a big difference. Go for gel or waxy formulas that glide on smoothly, skip shimmer-heavy finishes, and don’t be afraid to experiment. Confidence starts with what feels good on your skin.

FAQs

Question: What type of eyeliner is best for wrinkled eyelids?

Answer: Gel and waxy pencil eyeliners are best for wrinkled eyelids because they glide on smoothly without tugging or settling into lines.

Question: How do I keep eyeliner from smudging on mature skin?

Answer: Use a smudge-proof formula, apply concealer or primer first, and set your liner with eyeshadow or powder.

Question: What finish is best—matte or shimmer?

Answer: Matte or satin finishes work best on mature skin because they don’t emphasize texture or fine lines.

Question: Is liquid eyeliner okay for older eyes?

Answer: Liquid liner can work if you have steady hands, but it may crack or skip on textured skin. Gel or wax pencils are usually easier.

Next up: More Beauty Hacks You'll Love

About the Author:
Linda Robison is a Facial Fitness Specialist and the founder of Anti-Aging Beauty Zone. She shares expert insights on skincare, facial rejuvenation, and beauty treatments—blending traditional wisdom, personal experience, and science-backed research for both at-home and in-office solutions.

Before you go ....

Please tap on the💙in the bottom right corner if you found this page helpful. Also, Let’s CONNECT! Click the buttons below to follow me on social media.

Thanks so much!