Sudden Change vs. Plexaderm: My Results After Testing Both


Linda Robison
By: Linda Robison — Certified Facial Fitness Specialist
Disclosure: As an affiliate partner and Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Linda Robison
By: Linda Robison — Certified Facial Fitness Specialist
Disclosure: As an affiliate partner and Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

After testing Sudden Change against my experience with Plexaderm, I found that Sudden Change gave me a gentler tightening effect but a smoother, more comfortable finish. It didn't hold my under-eye puffiness as tightly as Plexaderm, but it stayed smooth and matte for over eight hours without flaking or peeling.

I've tested quite a few instant eye tighteners over the years, and most have one thing in common: they can make under-eye bags look better, but the white residue, cracking, and dryness can be frustrating.

Sudden Change caught my attention because it's different. It's a thin liquid that uses serum albumin rather than the silicate-based formula found in Plexaderm.

Sudden Change Under-Eye Firming Serum bottle used for my comparison with Plexaderm.The bottle of Sudden Change I tested on my under-eyes.

So I bought a bottle to see how it compared.

I tested it on my mature under-eye skin, which tends to be dry and shows fine lines easily. I tried Sudden Change on bare skin, mixed it with foundation as the directions suggest, and experimented with different amounts. Some applications looked better than others, and a few results surprised me.

Here's what I noticed, including the good, the not-so-good, and how it held up throughout the day.

Sudden Change vs. Plexaderm: At-a-glance comparison

What I compared Sudden Change Plexaderm
Formula Thin, albumin-based liquid Thicker, silicate-based serum
Tightening strength Gentler, less dramatic Stronger, more noticeable tightening
Under-eye puffiness Helped, but didn't hold puffiness as tightly Stronger temporary reduction in appearance
Finish Smooth and matte with a light application Tight-looking finish; can leave white residue
Flaking or cracking None during my normal 8+ hour test Can crack or leave visible residue, especially with too much product
Makeup Mixed well with foundation, but emphasized some fine lines I generally avoid under-eye makeup with it
Comfort Very comfortable; I almost forgot I had it on Stronger tightening sensation
Wear time Smooth, matte finish lasted over 8 hours; tightening gradually faded Still showing tightening at 8 hours, but looked freshest during the first 4–5 hours; more residue and caking later

How I tested Sudden Change on my under-eyes

I started by applying Sudden Change to clean, dry skin, following the directions to use two drops per eye and keep my face still for about three minutes while it dried.

With a light application, I liked the finish. My under-eye area looked smoother and more matte, without the obvious white residue I've experienced with some other tightening serums.

The tightening wasn't as strong as what I get from Plexaderm, but it looked natural and felt comfortable.

I also found that two light layers could look good, although applying too much gave me a very different result.

Close-up of my mature under-eye skin after a light application of Sudden Change, showing a smooth matte finish.Sudden Change applied lightly to my under-eye area. I liked the smooth, matte finish without visible flaking.

What happened when I applied too much Sudden Change?

Like most instant eye tighteners, Sudden Change works better when you don't overdo it.

I experimented with a thicker application and adding extra layers to see if I could get more tightening. At first it looked shiny, almost like I'd brushed egg whites onto my skin.

Close-up of my under-eye area looking shiny after applying too much Sudden Change eye tightener.Applying too much Sudden Change left a shiny, almost egg-white-like finish on my skin.

After a while, the thicker product began to look cracked and crystallized, similar to dried egg whites.

But here's what was different: It wasn't the usual white, chalky flaking I've experienced with Plexaderm and other instant eye tighteners. It had more of a shiny, cracked-film appearance.

Interestingly, I could apply two light layers and still get a nice, smooth finish. It was the heavier application and extra product that caused problems.

For me, more Sudden Change didn't mean better results. A lighter application looked much more natural.

Can you mix Sudden Change with foundation?

One thing that caught my attention was the makeup instructions. Unlike many instant eye tighteners I've tried, Sudden Change actually tells you that you can mix a couple of drops directly with a small amount of foundation.

I was curious, so I tried it.

To my surprise, the serum and foundation blended together really well. I didn't get the clumping or uneven finish I was expecting.

But once the mixture dried on my under-eye skin, several fine lines looked more noticeable.

Close-up of my mature under-eye skin showing noticeable fine lines after mixing Sudden Change serum with foundation.I mixed Sudden Change with foundation as directed. It blended easily, but my under-eye lines looked more noticeable.

Now, to be fair, I rarely wear foundation or concealer under my eyes for this very reason. My under-eye skin is dry, and makeup alone tends to emphasize those little lines.

So I can't blame Sudden Change entirely. The mixture applied nicely, but I didn't love how it looked on my skin.

My takeaway: Mixing Sudden Change with foundation worked better than I expected, but a smooth application doesn't necessarily mean a flattering finish, especially if your under-eye skin is dry or crepey.

What makes Sudden Change different from Plexaderm?

The biggest difference is the formula.

Plexaderm has a thicker, creamy serum consistency and uses silicate ingredients to create that strong, temporary tightening effect.

Sudden Change is almost watery. Instead of silicates, it contains bovine serum albumin, a protein that forms a tightening film as it dries on the skin.

Both work by temporarily tightening the skin's surface, making under-eye bags and fine lines look smoother and less noticeable. They don't actually treat the cause of the puffiness — they temporarily improve how it looks.

What interested me was whether Sudden Change's different formula would give me a smoother finish without the white, flaky residue I've experienced with other eye tighteners.

And that's where I noticed some interesting differences.

How long did Sudden Change last on my under-eyes?

This was probably the biggest surprise of my test.

With a light application, Sudden Change stayed smooth and matte for well over eight hours. I didn't notice any flaking, peeling, or visible breakdown during that time.

Even after a light workout, it still looked smooth and matte. I was surprised that there wasn't any visible cracking or peeling.

It also felt surprisingly comfortable. Unlike some instant eye tighteners that leave my skin feeling stiff, this one was so comfortable that I almost forgot I was wearing it.

But there's an important difference between how long a product looks good and how long it's actually tightening.

The initial tightening effect wasn't as strong as Plexaderm, and that tight feeling gradually faded. By nighttime, I could no longer see or feel much tightening.

I can't say exactly when that happened.

So while Sudden Change still looked great after eight hours, I can't say the actual tightening lasted that long.

Sudden Change vs. Plexaderm: Which would I choose?

If I wanted the strongest tightening effect for my under-eye bags, I'd still reach for Plexaderm or Peter Thomas Roth FIRMx.

Sudden Change just didn't give me that same level of tightening.

But I liked how it looked and felt. With a light application, it dried smooth and matte, stayed comfortable, and didn't leave the white, flaky residue I've experienced with some other eye tighteners.

I also think the matte finish helped make my remaining puffiness less noticeable. Without that shine, the little bumps and contours under my eyes didn't seem to stand out as much.

So I wouldn't rule it out. If you have milder puffiness or prefer a smoother, more natural-looking finish, Sudden Change might be worth trying.

For me, it comes down to what matters most: stronger tightening or a smoother, more comfortable finish.


Have a question or want to share your experience?

questions and comments

I'd love to hear from you! Visit my Questions & Comments page to ask a question, share a tip, or tell me what's worked for you.




Want to Stay in Touch?

Get my latest beauty tips, products I'm trying, little tricks I've discovered, and a few personal updates, too.

I'd love to keep you in the loop!


Linda Robison, certified facial fitness specialist and anti-aging advisor for women over 40

About the Author:

Linda Robison is a Certified Facial Fitness Specialist and founder of Anti-Aging Beauty Zone, where she shares practical tips, products, techniques, and at-home options for women over 40. She personally tests many of the methods she writes about.

Experience: Linda spent nearly 15 years as an Anti-Aging Health Advisor at the Life Extension Foundation and has over 30 years of experience testing facial anti-aging techniques, including training in Carolyn’s Facial Fitness. Her work has been featured in GB News and Beauty Box Magazine. You can view her background on LinkedIn and follow her on Pinterest.


Found this helpful? Tap the ♡ in the bottom right corner.


FOLLOW OR SAVE